Tuesday, April 17, 2007

Notes

Tuesday 10th and Wednesday 11th saw my second visit to my designated district, Beeston and Holbeck.

With the deadline approaching, i returned with cameras and pens and an open mind to try to demistify what the media makes of LS11. The only thing Beeston is famous for in the press is its connections to 7/7, which immediately projects a negative image on the community and, as they tend to, the news likes to make issue of racial and religious tension and the potential backlash such reportage inevitably insites. I grew up in Cleveland, a region synonymous with redundant industry, high unemployment and an exemplorary record for negative social statistics. Racial integration simply does not exist and prejudice is generally speaking still acceptable. I studied in Leeds at university and lived in Woodhouse for a year, then Hyde Park and Burley for two and a half more and loved it - a wonderful model for social harmony on the whole.

I found the reality of Beeston to be somewhat as reported, starting out at Cross Flats park and traveling the expanse of the postcode limits through Cottingley and Beeston Hill. In places, i felt a very honest sense of being intimidated. My impression is of back to back red brick housing, tight alleys and overcrowding in places. I know this is perhaps the norm for most average to poor towns and villages, it wasnt the kind of place you felt secure pulling out a DV cam or even a sketch book in parts. I kept gravitating to the green spaces, the clearings amongst the brick. These are so obviously important and yet so commodified in town planning, not particularly profitable. We all want greenspace in our backyards, we go to parks and woodland to recreate, we return to the ground when were gone and adorn memorial gardens with photographs and flowers. There is an intrinsic relationship with nature and the desire to be aligned with it, perhaps the over populating of residential space and no real sense of valuing escape doesnt solely breed but certainly helps to nurture a sense of individual, human depreciation? Is it that this oppressive social climate becomes a vehicle for disaffected groups to place blame on others, is it a far more primal urge to feel free or at least valued than just your prefered system of belief?

Then we have Holbeck. Experiencing a rapid regeneration and expansion programme - Holbeck Urban Village - this area essentially starts from the rear of the train station and granary wharf and touches borders with Beeston just this side of the M621. It is a thriving business district, vast sections of redundant industry and units being leveled to make way for expensive flats, impressive and beautitul modern buildings made of glass and steel, old insutrial rennovation projects, architects and design offices, media centres. In short, it is being set up as the professional and economic centre, a flagship for the success of Leeds' business enterprise. Conversely, it is a prominant red light district which comes alive in the late afternoon, presumely accomodating for and feeding from the offices and professionals on their way home. I dont intentionally go searching for the underbelly, it really is that blatant! And as an artist i really love this motif of glossing over those elements which dont look so good in the brochure. Im sure all elements of the professional trades are booming down there.

Im not trying to get ideas above my station here, but i desparately didnt want to tackle the surface issues that anyone could google and make a badge about. I really want to know what you all think about my experiences. Im not setting out to be awkward and to look for negative elements but when there is no denying that they exist and that there is such a grossly dis-proportionate investment in quality of status over quality of life, what do you do? The directional problem is that the intention of the Badge Project is to illustrate reasons for the end user to realise and engage with more than just the city centre, so presumably it is a positive image we need to be projecting...
Apologies for the length of this diatribe.
Looking forward to some thoughts.

Si










4 Comments:

At 8:11 PM, monitor said...

Hi Simon

The badge should be a response to your research, there is no stipulation that the resultant 'image' needs to be positive. However, we would encourage sensitivity to the area and who your local audience is. Where the badges are distributed from may also impact on this, as a negotiation will need to take place with the venue. A critcal response that comes from your artistic integrity would be encouraged.

We hope that helps clarify but please do keep in touch!

 
At 1:03 PM, Amelia said...

Hi Simon,

I lived on Cemetery Road Beeston (just over the M621) for a little over a year. Moving into a shared house there after I finished my degree as it was cheaper than Hyde Park.

I remember walking through Holbeck when I first went to look around the house and feeling quite threatened. This continued for a short time whilst living there, but as the environment became familiar it didn't seem any more intimidating than LS6.

I think in some ways your responses do give quite a representative view. I never felt comfortable walking around with a video camera, for example. Plus I do think parts of the area are quite depressing environments (it's a shame the M621 cut through what would've otherwise been a nice big park!)

However the terraces are like many other streets in many other cities. Some of the run down and some of them quite vibrant and well cared for.

I don't think that racial tension in Beeston is as bad as projected in the media. I found it hard to reconcile such negative images with my experience of the place. Maybe this is because I was a newcomer so didn't tap into more long term tensions. I'm not sure.

Over the time I spent there, I noticed the Holbeck terraces becoming more mixed in occupancy with different races (particularly Afro Caribbean and Polish) and 'young professionals' moving in.

Cottingley is just bizzarre. Rather ugly, and full of some horrid kids who get my bus. Yet I am touched by how some residents make the best of their space with nice gardens and so on.

I haven't drawn any conclusions from this...not sure any of it will really help but feel free to discuss!

Amelia.

 
At 4:51 PM, supanaught said...

Dear Amelia and Monitor

Many thanks for your comments. I felt it important to honestly communicate my experience and of course would handle subject matter and delivery sensitively. Im sure three short visits are not accurately representitive of living in an area and it wasnt that i walked the streets in constant fear! It was my opening experience which i think set me up on an odd keel - i parked in a street besides cross flats park and upon returning some hours later, was practically ushered back into my car by a large group of lads who were displaying particular interest in my tripod on my backpack - my mistake i guess.

I sympathise with what you say Amelia about people having pride in their homes and their neighbourhoods, i know teeside is the hell of the north but its still mine and there is intrinsically beauty to be found in everything if your looking with the right eyes. I think what perhaps affected me was the contrast between investing in business and investing in people socially, or rather the precident the former seems to take in the UK. And perhaps this is my thread...

Any thoughts are very welcome.
Many thanks

Si

 
At 7:48 PM, monitor said...

Hi Simon,

You're right about the investment in business. 'Holbeck Urban Village' is all shiny and fantastic and they're marketing it as a great place to live too. But the high spec flats are for city workers and people who are a bit more well off. It has no effect (at least not yet) on the Holbeck terraces. It will probably push up their prices but not push up quality of life.

How's it going trying to put all this in a badge design?

 

Post a Comment

<< Home